The smallbear one would be my choice. I imagine they would be the same grade of ferrite as the originals, which is what makes the old ones desireable. But its only after it has been in service for some time that it acquires the "desireable" characteristics. R G Keen (GEO FX) did some extensive testing of an old original unit & found that, due to the low grade of the ferrite material, after a while, due to the DC current flow through the inductor, the ferrite took on a small magnetic charge (its not supposed to) which affects the vocal quality of the wah (be mapped it out, pretty interesting). To get a new one to acquire the magnetic charge you would leave it powered up 24/7 for however long you could. He does suggest ways to simulate the effect by using a small audio transformer as the inductor & running a small DC component through the unused secondary winding to produce the magnetic offset. Would take a bit of experimenting I would image. I think Steve Daniels (smallbear proprietor) would know if the halo type he stocks is the same grade of ferrite as the old ones. Be good to know. Cheers