I have only one guitar with a maple neck, and it's my '06 MIM Fender Tele '72 Deluxe replica...
I actually love the neck. It took me some time to get used to, since it's a different shape than
any other guitar I own. AND it's covered in polyurethane, as I believe all non-USA Fender guitars are.
To me this lovely piece of blonde maple on my black Telecaster is really beautiful... BUT
I had some trouble getting used to this instrument on my own... I wanted to very badly
because I love the tone and the look and all. A couple of things really helped me turn
this guitar into a very comfortable friend to make music with.
1. I broke down and took it in for professional setup. I thought I had got it right, but
since I wasn't relating to it very well, I decided to spend some money, and either I would
like it more or it would be easier to sell with a pro setup. I turned out to like it MUCH more,
so what ever they did was very worth it. That was at least five years ago, and it's been great
ever since.
2. On advice from other members on ETSG, I scrubbed the back of the neck with a green kitchen cleaning pad.
I had tried with some steel wool (outside, on a windy day, with the wind carrying the steel crumbs AWAY from
my pickups). But the green kitchen scrubbie really did a number on the polyurethane coating on the back of
the neck. I believe it took a layer of it off... and roughed up the hard slick poly. Then I smoothed it with
the steel wool again and it made a huge difference. It's still hard but it doesn't feel like plastic. It's smooth
but not sticky in any way.
So I voted for maple necks for Fender guitars. I never had any trouble with the fretboard side of this neck.
The fretboard looks great, some maple grain shows, and the frets are solid and easy to work with.
I also do NOT like the looks of an old maple Fender neck with the finish worn away in spots and a lot of dirt and dead
punk skin worked into the cracks in the lacquer. My Tele may escape this fate because the neck is covered in
polyurethane. I dunno. The poly shows no cracks or divots, and the guitar is ten years old.
To me that just goes to show that polyurethane is a very practical finish for guitars.
People go all giddy with enthusiasm over lacquer, and I can't argue with that because it's traditional.
Most of the guitars I own were varnished with lacquer. On some of them it's badly worn.
But my two Epiphones and my MIM Tele and MIC P-Bass all sport polyurethane finishes , and it seems hard
and nearly impervious to anything but boshing the guitar with a brick. Go figure...
Anyway, I stick with my vote for maple on a Fender. I think it's hard to beat.
