Yes an there's a place on this boat for all of us... I do love my Gibsons.
AND a used Gibson retains value better than other brands.
I confess that if I owned an '05 Gibson ES-335 '59 RI,
I would be very slow to sell it.
Maybe being pore would make me value it more than its former owner did... Dunno.
I regard the ES-335 as one of Gibson's best designs, as I also regard the SG.
I had to sell a lot of my most favored possessions this year, due to unexpected medical
problems suffered by my ladylove. I sold my boat, I sold my gun collection, I sold about half of
my instruments including all of my 'vintage' ones. I sold my house. I sold fishing lures and
gave away a lot of my cool things that nobody would buy. I gave away my hunting gear and
thick North Country camo coveralls. I knew I wouldn't need those things in Tucson.
But I didn't sell my Gibsons. And I didn't sell my Epiphone ES 339. I 'fostered" it at the home
of another player, who I know will play it and change the strings once in a while. So I didn't have
to transport it after my home was sold. And I know where it is, and can get it back (I think).
We'll see if my friend bonds with the Epi the way I did. He's already fallen arse over teakettle for
my Tele deluxe. And his wife has too, so I know that will get played also.
I miss my Epiphone, but I have a fine (small) collection of instruments to comfort me.
I kept the five on the right with me, and I have them now...
the Epi and the Fender are in the arms of good friends.
To return to thread: I have to say that IMHO the Epiphone is a fine substitute. The Gibson costs eight times as much
and has also a plywood top, and is also a semi-hollow design. If I had one, I would treasure it, but since I don't I
can rock just fine with the Epi. It was cheap enough for me to afford to mod it just the way I like it, so I have a dream
guitar in disguise. I like that very much.
Gibson elegance is not cheap... unless like me you luck into some great deals on guitars that have it.
But it's worth it if you have the dough ray me. If you do, more power to you.
So our '67Plexi is not wrong to favor it. But any of us would not go wrong
to favor the sturdy practicality of a MIM Fender like my Tele, or the amazing versatility
of a humble Epiphone like the blonde above with the mouse ears
and the jangly (or tough and gritty) P-90s.