I do like volutes for their aesthetic qualities; I realize some don't like them. However, be careful about expecting the volute to prevent headstock breaks (if that is your expectation). It doesn't. My '74 SG's headstock broke...right through the volute.
I like the feel of the volutes...
The original EDS-1275 neck specifications from Gibson are as follows:
Thickness at Fret 1: Both 6 and 12 String are 2.032 cm / .800"
Thickness at Fret 12: Both 6 and 12 String are 2.54 cm / 1.00"
Average Weight: .453 kg / 1.25 lbs (each neck)
I had these necks made with Volutes and they will measure 1" all the way fromt 12th fret to the nut. This is very close to the original EDS-1275 specifications of 1.00' - .800" but closer to the specifications on my Gibson SG T Series SG of 1.00" at the 12th fret and .951" at the nut - a neck that I find extremely comfortable.
All the Von Herndon Tele-esque guitars have a 1" "Log Profile" neck and it has proven to be very popular and comfortable, although I have been asked to offer a "Slim Taper" on a couple of them, with a first fret thickness in the .800" range...
For comparison, have a look at a Warmoth "fat Back" neck profile:
Fatback
- Similar to: Vintage Fender® 1950's deep "U"
- Thickness at 1st Fret: 1.00"
- Thickness at 12th Fret: 1.00"
The Fatback is our thickest, roundest neck profile, made for players who love a fat vintage feel.