Tone is everywhere.
To me tone is just sound.
That juicy stinker in the first example, it had tone.
If someone shoves you down a flight of stairs, your screams and the thud you make at the bottom, have tone.
If a tree falls in the woods and no one hears it, it still had tone. If that tree happened to be Brazilian Rosewood, it must have had fantastic tone.
But, perception of tone is in the hearing.
You may hear something incredible and someone else hearing the same thing, they may just hear noise.
So is tone in the ears? Even deeper is tone defined by your hearing?
What if you can't hear? Is your world void of tone?
How would you define tone to a deaf person.
I was sitting in a bar a few weeks ago listening to a friends band and there was a guy at the bar drinking a beer, trying to communicate with my wife & I.
It was quite obvious to me he was deaf, possibly mute as well.
But he had something to say to us & she was getting annoyed with his gesturing and pounding on the bar not quite realizing the whole picture. She just thought he was one of the oddball street people that hangs around downtown.
Though he couldn't hear a thing, he was appreciating the music through the vibrations in the bar, the wooden floor and the barstool.
That's what he was "saying". He liked the music and the band.
Once she realized the situation, she felt bad for being annoyed with him.
Anyway we bought him a beer and we all continued to enjoy the show.
Watching him, you could tell he was into it.
He could feel the beat. His head feet and hands were all connected to the music.
At break time my buddy in the band came over to chat and I introduced him to my new friend.
The fellow acted like he just met Clapton. It made his night.
So it obviously wasn't tone this cat was attracted to, but what was it?
It reached deeper into this cats soul.
So my question is can there be tone without rhythm and beat?