So, we made some changes. After a lot of discussion, we agreed that the lead guitarist had to go. From day one, we realized his charisma and "wildcard" nature was going to be difficult to deal with, but his dynamic playing and stage persona was advantageous to our overall stage appeal. However, it seemed as though everything we suggested would trigger a barrage of texts - or phone calls - to complain about how this "wasn't the right way to do things." For me, the straw that broke the camel's back came when he recently refused to play an outdoor "street festival" in a mountain community complaining that
"I'm not playing on a sidewalk. If I don't have a legitimate stage, I'm not going."
I think he will do well as a bandleader, but it just isn't in his personality to be a part of the team.
Guitarist #3 was also dropped. He just wasn't putting in the effort to get the songs nailed down and there were a significant number of mistakes that kept being repeated week after week. I think he is a great dud and all, but we simply must have people who are "100% in" and this wasn't the case. I've also evaluated our sound and we agreed it's best to just stick with twin guitars.
Today is first rehearsal with new lead guitarist...