
From the StewMac website, about the ColorTone touch-up marker pen:Looks great!
If you want shine, you must buff, but be sure to apply amply coats of lacquer first.
I am not sure how adding nitro from the pen would "melt" the existing nitro (or even poly). Maybe they are adhering to each other and it looks like melting?
The reason I didn’t apply the lacquer before was partly a brainfart.It doesn't look great when highlighted in that way. The other pictures you showed which are closer to real world conditions looked pretty good. I did kinda wonder why you put the lacquer on the button on the guitar instead of doing that first then gluing it in later; I thought it might be asking for trouble because nitro is so sensitive...
But, as you say, 9 times out of 10, just playing, neither you nor anybody around will notice anything at all, so it does the job. Camera lighting can really make things look different from how they are in person...
I figure I’m going to play this guitar until it is naturally reliced to death anyway, so it doesn’t matter. Any resale value is screwed because of my mods (most of the original parts are long gone), and I’ve invested my soul in this one. This prticular mod is reversible, though. Any small finish blemishes should be fixable.Yeah, I'm sure it's a decent enough job and you (and others) simply won't notice it... Under the 'microscope' I found little scrape marks on my binding a couple of weeks ago. Now, even looking for them it's really hard to find them, and you'd never notice them unless you were looking closely for them... We tend to get a bit crazy with our detailing when in reality there's no problem - it's good.