Now…TC electronics “The Sentry”. Plays well with the finicky pedals, fuzz, wah, treble booster etc. Transparent.What noise gate are you using?
Have also enjoyed the venerable Boss NS2 over many years. Some of the finicky pedals need to be placed carefully for best results. It has a sound/feel.
Also tried the EHX Silencer. Not at all what I wanted. If you ever wanna try it, let me know.