Battle of the Bands The Doors vs Black Sabbath

Who wins this battle


  • Total voters
    22
  • Poll closed .

TVvoodoo

Ambassador of The Comfortably Slung
Country flag
RUSH takes UFO handily according the TTR voting population.

tourney ladder .jpg

Now it's time to get a little darker. The Doors might be considered a bit more 1960's band than a 70's band but are well within the window 1968-1980 here with some very important releases, however they only managed five albums
over a six year period starting in '66 and it all crashed down when enigmatic singer Jim Morrison joined "Club 27" in 1971 Morrison was known as much as poet as a lyricist, with a penchant for dark and spooky lyrical themes, but they could
also bring a jazzy lightness to juxtapose with darker creations via the keyboardist Manzarek and guitarist Krieger, the
Doors made the Morrisons dark lyrics float over accessible, airy backgrounds, or flat out blues.

Black Sabbath had the first release in 1970, with the famous self-titled debut album, and with various
different singers, after Ozzy was dumped by his longtime bandmates in 1978 for substance abuse issues.

Sabbath went on to release new music with various frontmen, reuniting with Osbourne much later on for a final release.

Both bands (particulary the frontment) were certainly fueled to an extent by drugs and alcohol. Both explored rather dark themes so it's kind of fitting. Many consider Sabbath the be the first true heavy metal band, and the doors would be more psychedelic blues with of pop sensibilities, and there were certainly sprinkles of blues psychedelia in the Sabbath catalog too. Guitarist Tony Iommi use of "The Devils Interval" or diabolus in musica - a tritone interval which is part of the blues scale, leaning heavily on ponderous riffs favoring this musical flavour infusing a dark/evil sound to the music, that worked well with darker occult/alternate song themes. But Sabbath were no one trick ponies they were unafraid to explore a variety of musical styles... one of the more endearing factors of the band to many.

I'll admit I don't know too much about either band, but I would say I enjoy them equally, though some would say I favour the wrong
kind of Sabbath, just out of this time period which true Sabbath fans might frown upon.



Who deserves to move on in this contest?
 
Last edited:
Sorry but this is apples and oranges to me. I have nothing against The Doors but outside of The End which is legendary for opening up Apocalypse In Now! and Break on Thru? Nothing grabs my attention. I mean how do you trust a band with no bassist?! Lmao

Sabbath on the other hand? What can you say about them? They started it all: the true godfathers of heavy metal. You wouldn't normally be grateful for a horrific maiming, but that sheet metal press that took Tony Iommi's middle and ring finger tips off, accidentally helped create metal by him having to detune to ease string tension.

They wrote stuff back in 1970 that is still incredibly heavy by today's standards and Volume 4? That's their masterpiece as far as I'm concerned. Under the Sun? Name me something as brooding as that riff! Especially the intro and outro

Sabbath by a marathon


 
Couple of very different, iconic(to some), SG wielding guitarists in this one though.
I'm just ripping on them for the bass thing lol I actually don't mind The Doors and Robby Kreiger is a fine guitarist in his own right. My wife and father in law are big Doors fans, so they're a group a listen to whether I intend to or not, so it grows on me lol

I have, however, paid my pilgrimage years ago back in Paris in 2008
FB_IMG_1741234362453.jpg

And this is one of the greatest bits I have ever seen. A must-see for any Doors fan!
 
In the early '90s I grew to absolutely love the Doors. As much as Jim was a complete A$$hat his intensity and swag could not be beat. One of the most iconic front-men of all time IMO. This is probably the hardest call of all the competitions but I'm throwing one in for the Lizard King.
 
Last edited:
Ummmmm…..”Dave’s not here man”…
Jim…James….the middle initial “D” stands for Douglas…27 when he left iirc.
Is everybody in?…
This matchup kinda sucks. I like both very much, for very different reasons.
You and other Doors Fans have lost me. It should be my era but it’s not.
There are bands in that era that I favor like Alice Cooper Band , James Gang .
 
Back
Top