All Along The Watchtower - Meanings and Thoughts???

Inspector #20

Ambassador of Tone
Fallen Star
Country flag
I have always looked for the deeper meaning in everything. This song is very intriguing to me on a number of levels, because, to me, it represents a view on our society from both the perspectives of the poor and the wealthy elite.

In medieval times, the joker, or jester, was the equivalent of a modern-day stand-up comedian who provided entertainment and humor for royalty. It was not considered to be a highly respected job. In many ways, Jokers were social outcasts, and, to some extent, we have proof of this in historical letters from the period. Many jesters were found to have committed some act of impropriety which caused them to be cast out. Many were musicians according to historical records. Jesters could also be killed for failing to entertain their masters, so in many ways, they were - from historical writings - a type of indentured servant.

In the context of Hendrix's song, the Joker ponders the status quo. He has a conversation with a common thief - someone who would also be in the same class as he - a type of social outcast, about his view on society. The joker complains to the thief about his role in society and in the culture.

"There must be some kind of way outta here," I take as meaning a way out of servitude and to freedom. The joker sees the wealthy who consume his "wine," which I believe is an observation on hos the wealthy can enslave men, take their lives and dictate to them what they can and cannot do. The joker also notices the common man is left to dig his earth and he sees the two social classes as completely and totally unbalanced. Neither class understands the other - They are separated on every level, and yet, the joker sees that neither class really understands the meaning of life and freedom.

The thief comments on the joker's complaints in a calm voice and basically tells him to keep his cool. The thief realizes that many members of royalty see life as a joke - meaning that the taking of a common life by a nobleman isn't even punishable and in effect, the meaning of the common man's life "is but a joke."

The thief recognizes that both he and the joker are in a perilous social situation because both have a death sentence upon them - the thief for criminal conduct and the joker could face death if he did not please the nobility. The thief acknowledges that both he and the joker have been through this situation, but both have escaped the fate - the thief through his cunning nature and the joker by maintaining himself in the good graces of nobility. The thief tells the joker that he should stop complaining because times are soon to change - as the hour is getting late.

The focus now shifts to the princes along the watchtower. Watchtowers foretell off danger to the inhabitants of a castle - in this case, the danger that the upper class could befall if the lower class were allowed to break free. The prince seems to reflect on his life of luxury. His women come and go and foot servants follow him and attend to his every need.

He looks out into the distance and hears the wildcat growl. This free, wild beast, represents the danger of a free class of common people. The two riders are the first two horsemen of the apocalypse. The prince sees his world crumbling before him...
 
I have always looked for the deeper meaning in everything. This song is very intriguing to me on a number of levels, because, to me, it represents a view on our society from both the perspectives of the poor and the wealthy elite.

In medieval times, the joker, or jester, was the equivalent of a modern-day stand-up comedian who provided entertainment and humor for royalty. It was not considered to be a highly respected job. In many ways, Jokers were social outcasts, and, to some extent, we have proof of this in historical letters from the period. Many jesters were found to have committed some act of impropriety which caused them to be cast out. Many were musicians according to historical records. Jesters could also be killed for failing to entertain their masters, so in many ways, they were - from historical writings - a type of indentured servant.

In the context of Hendrix's song, the Joker ponders the status quo. He has a conversation with a common thief - someone who would also be in the same class as he - a type of social outcast, about his view on society. The joker complains to the thief about his role in society and in the culture.

"There must be some kind of way outta here," I take as meaning a way out of servitude and to freedom. The joker sees the wealthy who consume his "wine," which I believe is an observation on hos the wealthy can enslave men, take their lives and dictate to them what they can and cannot do. The joker also notices the common man is left to dig his earth and he sees the two social classes as completely and totally unbalanced. Neither class understands the other - They are separated on every level, and yet, the joker sees that neither class really understands the meaning of life and freedom.

The thief comments on the joker's complaints in a calm voice and basically tells him to keep his cool. The thief realizes that many members of royalty see life as a joke - meaning that the taking of a common life by a nobleman isn't even punishable and in effect, the meaning of the common man's life "is but a joke."

The thief recognizes that both he and the joker are in a perilous social situation because both have a death sentence upon them - the thief for criminal conduct and the joker could face death if he did not please the nobility. The thief acknowledges that both he and the joker have been through this situation, but both have escaped the fate - the thief through his cunning nature and the joker by maintaining himself in the good graces of nobility. The thief tells the joker that he should stop complaining because times are soon to change - as the hour is getting late.

The focus now shifts to the princes along the watchtower. Watchtowers foretell off danger to the inhabitants of a castle - in this case, the danger that the upper class could befall if the lower class were allowed to break free. The prince seems to reflect on his life of luxury. His women come and go and foot servants follow him and attend to his every need.

He looks out into the distance and hears the wildcat growl. This free, wild beast, represents the danger of a free class of common people. The two riders are the first two horsemen of the apocalypse. The prince sees his world crumbling before him...

I think one of the great things about many of Bob Dylan's greatest songs is the levels of interpretation that are possible, and Watchtower is one of the greatest. I think your interpretation here is well thought out and a very valid analysis of it, especially in light of modern society as seen through the lens of the time it was written.
 
I try not to think about it much---- many songs I tried to "understand" in my youth I later found out -- "Oh we just threw it together on the car ride to the studio"--the lyrics) or

dunno -- our bass players girlfriend wrote em on a napkin in the bog waiting for us to complete an interview-----
 
Not being a native English speaker, I consider myself lucky. I can just "turn off" the lyrics and just enjoy the sound of the voice on top of the instruments. I love music mostly for the music, the poetry is not very important to me.

I can understand about 98% of the lyrics in English, German and Spanish but I just don't if I don't want to.

Music > poetry.
 
My take on the meaning behind the lyrics?

Life sucks and people are jerks.

Pretty much the same meaning behind lots of songs, albeit using interesting imagery.

Here’s my short list of the meanings behind many songs:

Life sucks.

Life is great.

I love you.

I hate you.

I need more money.

I got lots of money.

You treat me wrong.

You treat me right.

I wanna “be with” you tonight.

I don’t wanna “be with” you...ever.

You’re hot.

You’re not.

I’m leaving you.

I’ll never leave you.

My car is cool.

My truck broke down.

Of course, there are more, but just think of how many songs can be boiled down to these basic themes!
 
Last edited:
I try not to think about it much---- many songs I tried to "understand" in my youth I later found out -- "Oh we just threw it together on the car ride to the studio"--the lyrics) or

dunno -- our bass players girlfriend wrote em on a napkin in the bog waiting for us to complete an interview-----

I think that my mind - just naturally - looks for the deeper meaning in everything....
 
My take on the meaning behind the lyrics?

Life sucks and people are jerks.

Pretty much the same meaning behind lots of songs, albeit using interesting imagery.

Here’s my short list of the meanings behind many songs:

Life sucks.

Life is great.

I love you.

I hate you.

I need more money.

I got lots of money.

You treat me wrong.

You treat me right.

I wanna “be with” you tonight.

I don’t wanna “be with” you...ever.

You’re hot.

You’re not.

I’m leaving you.

I’ll never leave you.

My car is cool.

My truck broke down.

Of course, there are more, but just think of how many songs can be boiled down to these basic themes!

Sounds like you just covered the country music genre... :-)

I cannot help but see deeper into everything...
 
Not being a native English speaker, I consider myself lucky. I can just "turn off" the lyrics and just enjoy the sound of the voice on top of the instruments. I love music mostly for the music, the poetry is not very important to me.

I can understand about 98% of the lyrics in English, German and Spanish but I just don't if I don't want to.

Music > poetry.

Some songs I dig just for the musical arrangement. 'Round And Round' by Ratt is one such song. Subsequently, if a song has a weak sound or arrangement, I may never, ever listen to it in its entirety, so it's a real balancing act for me to be drawn in by the music, and then intrigued by the lyrics.

However, I like stories and love lyrical journey's, so I am always caught up in the deep meanings behind some songs and the inherent mystery contained therein. A good example would be Dio's 'Fever Dreams.'
 
I try not to think about it much---- many songs I tried to "understand" in my youth I later found out -- "Oh we just threw it together on the car ride to the studio"--the lyrics) or

dunno -- our bass players girlfriend wrote em on a napkin in the bog waiting for us to complete an interview-----

Like Gball pointed out earlier, it's a beautiful thing that we can derive our own interpretations from songs.
 
I think one of the great things about many of Bob Dylan's greatest songs is the levels of interpretation that are possible, and Watchtower is one of the greatest. I think your interpretation here is well thought out and a very valid analysis of it, especially in light of modern society as seen through the lens of the time it was written.

Dylan certainly was a storyteller!

Being an only child, who grew up as a kind of social outcast (small, rather backwards farming community) I read intensely in hopes that I could educate myself sufficiently one day to leave that place. The role of the joker and thief held a lot of significance for me in Dylan's song. I identified personally with their perspective...
 
Just adding:

being a Portuguese speaker is a blessing for someone like me.

Being able to just "switch off" the lyrics gives me a "bidimentional" ability to listen to music.

I can listen to Stairway to heaven either just enjoying the sound and travelling through its instruments and the pitch of Plant's voicings, OR I can listen to the song and actually listen to what Plant is saying, digging into Page's occult teachings...
 
Oh, I explore deeper meanings, too. And, I enjoy doing it. But, I cut to the chase, too!


For certain...kind of depends on the song i think....

Sometimes, it’s more fun to immediately drive to the pithy bottom line of a song that is intended to be more deep and thoughtful.

I never acted up in school, so it’s just my equivalent of throwing paper airplanes in class!
 
Back
Top