Here's the story: After decades of tone-chasing and buying/selling pretty much everything out there, including a whole bunch of "boutique" pedals, I had the realization that none of it really made
that much difference. Huge outlays in time and cash for incremental or nonexistent changes in tone. So I decided to simplify, sold all the other pedals and got this easy-to-transport Boss board and a bunch of indestructible Boss pedals (plus the Cry Baby). It's simple, portable, and relatively inexpensive. Plus, in my experience the Boss stuff sounds just as good as anything sitting in a mix, so.
And know what? I have never, ever been happier with a pedalboard setup.
The only thing that really changes is the dirt pedal - I have this Blues Driver, a Boss Distortion and a Boss Fuzz which I switch around depending on what I am playing. The BD is really only used as a clean boost, but the distortion is used for hard rock and the fuzz for more modern stuff, and these are always set pretty low as I get 95% of my grind from the amps. Also, I don't keep any of the channels on my amps clean, I have them set up for 2 different dirty sounds, so with one pedal out front I have 4 levels of crunch/distortion that I can footswitch between.
The rest is probably pretty self-explanatory and in front of the amp its: Wah -> tuner -> phaser set for a swirly almost auto-wha kind of sound, really great for that Judas Priest kind of solo tone -> whichever dirt box I need that day -> amp.
In the loop are: Chorus, which I just use to give tight crunchy sounds some body and shimmer and to help solo tones get out in front of the mix -> Delay, which I use set to the brighter modern mode, and use for "atmospheric" single-note rhythm stuff and wet soloing. I do not like reverb and so don't ever use it, but if I need some moisture in the tone I get it from the delay -> Looper, which of course is for writing/practicing alone.
That's it, all I need right there.