When Strings Go Bad:

Inspector #20

Ambassador of Tone
Fallen Star
Country flag
My double neck rarely, if ever, needs tuning. After playing it a lot today, I notice the 'b' and 'e' began going both sharp and flat, almost constantly. These strings are only about 2 weeks old, and I am using the same brand and gauge (EB .010's) as always.

Is this likely a characteristic of the strings just simply going south???
 
From the Web:

Hindsight is 20/20.

Right after you break a string in the middle of a show, you say to yourself, I knew I should have changed my strings! But how can you tell when it’s time for a change, before it’s too late?

As always, the answer lies in paying closer attention to your guitar, and listening to what it has to tell you. If you think it’s time to change your strings, you’re probably right.

Pay special attention to these 5 signs, as they may give you an early clue your strings are close to breaking—and mean the difference between playing a great show, and being embarrassed mid-set.

1. Your guitar strings won’t stay in tune

Most of the time, tuning problems with guitar strings occur either with brand new strings, or old ones. When you first put on new strings you can fight the tuning problems by stretching the strings out a bit the first few times you play them. But once that period has passed, your guitar strings should stay in tune—until they don’t.

If you’ve had the same strings on your guitar for more than a week or two, and you start to notice they don’t hold tune as well as they did a few days beforehand, it might be time to change your strings.

2. Your guitar’s tone is dull

We all know the familiar snap of brand new strings. They’re bright, present, and crisp. Some guitarists love the sound of fresh strings and change them every few days to keep it up. Other players like the more mellow tone of broken in strings and find the sweet spot to be between one and four weeks into the strings’ life.

Regardless of your preference, your strings should never sound dull or flat, the way that really old strings can. If you’re diming your amp’s treble knob and you still sound like Wes Montgomery, it’s time to change your guitar strings.

3. Your guitar strings are discolored

When we play guitar, the oils from our fingers build up on the strings over time, leaving them more prone to corrosion, and eventually breakage.

An early sign that your strings are on their last legs is their color. As nickel and steel guitar strings age they lose their luster, turning a sort of dull gray color. Bronze acoustic strings lose their copper-colored sheen and turn a darker brown color. As soon as you start to see discoloration on your guitar strings, it’s a good idea to slap on a new set.

4. Your guitar strings feel stiff

Your guitar strings should always feel flexible and bendable (unless of course you’re playing extra heavy strings without drop-tuning). Once they start to feel stiff, it means the metal is begin the process of corrosion.

Now this doesn’t necessarily mean that your strings are going to break that day, but it does mean that your guitar isn’t playing or sounding its best. At the very least, early signs of corrosion in your guitar strings should be a signal that it’s time to order a spare set to keep around, just in case.

5. Your guitar strings feel dirty

Obviously this ties in with reason #3, but sometimes it’s easier to feel your guitar strings’ age than it is to see it. When you slide your fingers along your strings, they should feel smooth, almost slippery. If there’s any friction between your fingers and the strings, it’s likely a sign of dirt getting in the way.

Dirty strings not only sound duller than fresh strings, they also hamper your ability to move around the fretboard, making it less likely that you’re playing your best.

If you’re passionate about your playing and your tone, it’s worth the extra couple of bucks a month to keep your guitar playing and sounding its best, and one of the easiest ways to do that is to stay on top of changing your guitar strings.


 
Well, Dangit Robert, I freakin hate being so negligent. I buy a guitar one day, and a day later, I break a high E while bending.
I can't believe some jerk didn't take better care of MY strings before I bought the 42 year old guitar.
 
Y'know...the article that Robert posted got me to thinking...I haven't broken an electric guitar string in, like, forever.

I wonder if they're just making strings better than they used to. I generally play them until the life goes out of the tone.
 
Well, Dangit Robert, I freakin hate being so negligent. I buy a guitar one day, and a day later, I break a high E while bending.
I can't believe some jerk didn't take better care of MY strings before I bought the 42 year old guitar.

I been killing strings lately, but I am playing longer and more aggressively too..
 
Y'know...the article that Robert posted got me to thinking...I haven't broken an electric guitar string in, like, forever.

I wonder if they're just making strings better than they used to. I generally play them until the life goes out of the tone.

I been killing strings lately, but I am playing longer and more aggressively too..

Maybe that's it. I do play a lot lighter than I used to. Even when I look like I'm hitting the strings hard, I'm not really digging in too deeply. Maybe that's why I don't break strings, anymore.
 
I'm an aggressive bender of sorts. It's rare that I break a string. Usually They get used and need changing. A couple months ago I broke a string on two guitars, the same week.(one fixed , one lock trem, both D'Addario) Thought it was strange. I was practicing an ACDC lead with a big bend, and ker- snap. I chalk it up to coincidence, cause it almost never happens.
 
Maybe that's it. I do play a lot lighter than I used to. Even when I look like I'm hitting the strings hard, I'm not really digging in too deeply. Maybe that's why I don't break strings, anymore.

I've just been playing more and more of late and I like the dynamics I get from pick attack, so I guess I'm at fault, not Ernie...
 
I'm an aggressive bender of sorts. It's rare that I break a string. Usually They get used and need changing. A couple months ago I broke a string on two guitars, the same week.(one fixed , one lock trem, both D'Addario) Thought it was strange. I was practicing an ACDC lead with a big bend, and ker- snap. I chalk it up to coincidence, cause it almost never happens.

All my breaks take place near the tuning key - between the keys and nut.

Last week, I had a .017" 'G' string start slipping on me. I noticed the wrap had slipped and choked up around the ball, but it didn't break.
 
Y'know...the article that Robert posted got me to thinking...I haven't broken an electric guitar string in, like, forever.

I wonder if they're just making strings better than they used to. I generally play them until the life goes out of the tone.

I think they are a lot better. I used to break strings on the reg in the '80's and '90's. But I honestly can't remember the last time I broke one, at least a decade. Strings last about 5-6 playing hours for me before they start to feel lifeless, a few more hours before the sound goes. So, I change strings on guitar I play a lot every week or two.
 
I think they are a lot better. I used to break strings on the reg in the '80's and '90's. But I honestly can't remember the last time I broke one, at least a decade. Strings last about 5-6 playing hours for me before they start to feel lifeless, a few more hours before the sound goes. So, I change strings on guitar I play a lot every week or two.

Interesting...what I notice is they just start going flat and sharp.
 
It's an abstract thing with me.
Sometimes I pick up one of my guitars
and it whispers "change my strings please"
When that happens I change them right then and there.
I have not broken a string on a job in many moons.
 
It's an abstract thing with me.
Sometimes I pick up one of my guitars
and it whispers "change my strings please"
When that happens I change them right then and there.
I have not broken a string on a job in many moons.

Mine whisper, "Hey, you deserve more beer..."
 
It's an abstract thing with me.
Sometimes I pick up one of my guitars
and it whispers "change my strings please"
When that happens I change them right then and there.
I have not broken a string on a job in many moons.

With a 12 string, breaking the high octave 'G' is a normal thing. I get about 2 weeks out of them
 
I've just been playing more and more of late and I like the dynamics I get from pick attack, so I guess I'm at fault, not Ernie...
If you like Ernie Balls, look into their new Paradigms. Expensive at about $15 a set. But the construction at the ball ends is over the top. They're suppose to be the most durable strings on the market. Ernie Ball Strings has a series of demo ads for their Paradigms that are amusing. My favorite is with Paul Gilbert:

All my breaks take place near the tuning key - between the keys and nut.
I've had this happen twice recently... breakage at the post. But this was due to setting up a couple guitars. A lot of tuning to pitch and then releasing tension for nut work and intonation adjustments. Otherwise, it has been many years since I broke a string by bending. And when it did break, it was usually at the bridge saddles.
 
With a 12 string, breaking the high octave 'G' is a normal thing. I get about 2 weeks out of them

That sounds like an engineer I used to work with.
He was constantly replacing HF driver diaphragms.
He used to say "That's the nature of the business".
I used to say "No. You're doing something wrong".
Turns out his system was clipping at around 20K.
I went around and around with him about this.
We eventually solved the problem.

Is it possible you have a burr on that particular
bridge saddle or at the tuning key hole?
 
If you like Ernie Balls, look into their new Paradigms. Expensive at about $15 a set. But the construction at the ball ends is over the top. They're suppose to be the most durable strings on the market. Ernie Ball Strings has a series of demo ads for their Paradigms that are amusing. My favorite is with Paul Gilbert:


I've had this happen twice recently... breakage at the post. But this was due to setting up a couple guitars. A lot of tuning to pitch and then releasing tension for nut work and intonation adjustments. Otherwise, it has been many years since I broke a string by bending. And when it did break, it was usually at the bridge saddles.

I notice they don't claim them to be stronger than Herman Li.... :-)
 
That sounds like an engineer I used to work with.
He was constantly replacing HF driver diaphragms.
He used to say "That's the nature of the business".
I used to say "No. You're doing something wrong".
Turns out his system was clipping at around 20K.
I went around and around with him about this.
We eventually solved the problem.

Is it possible you have a burr on that particular
bridge saddle or at the tuning key hole?

They real between nut and key in the great wide open...
 
Back
Top