The Battle of the Bands AC/DC vs The Who >> STILL OPEN!!! <<

Which group Deserves to Move on

  • AC/DC

    Votes: 15 48.4%
  • The Who

    Votes: 16 51.6%

  • Total voters
    31
  • Poll closed .
@Clockworkmike if you were in early caveman society, you'd the dude poo-pooing the invention of the reed flute because loudly banging a drum with an old thigh bone is plenty good enough for you. :ROFLMAO:
I think of it rather sophisticatedly, really. In the words of the poet lauret, Sir Ronald Belford Scott:
"They say that you play too loud
Well, baby, that's tough
They say that you've got too much
Can't get enough
They tell you that you look a fool
Or maybe I'm a fool for you
State that your mind's diseased
Shakey stuff
And it's a rock 'n' roll damnation
Ma's own whipping boy
Rock 'n' roll damnation
Take your chance, while you still got the choice"

The great sage-wordsmith, Chaim Witz also penned the great tome

"Turn it up, hungry for the medicine
Two-fisted to the very end
No more treated like aliens
We're not gonna take it

No lies, no more alibis
Turn it up got me hypnotized
Rock on, won't be tranquilized

'Cause I love it loud, I wanna hear it loud, right between the eyes
Loud, I wanna hear it loud, don't want no compromise"

Lmao, see? Not a caveman, but rather literary in my tastes
 
Well. This was exciting! OK. We're going to set this vote aside for now and revisit later on. I tried to extend it for 24 hours but I was 30 seconds late on that.
 
Screenshot_20250312-201714_X.jpg
Between 1968 and 1980, The Who and AC/DC carved distinct paths in rock history, each leaving an indelible mark through hits, sales, critical acclaim, artistic merit, and sheer face-melting power.
The Who, already established by 1968, evolved from their mod roots into a groundbreaking force. Their 1969 rock opera Tommy was a seismic hit, spawning singles like “Pinball Wizard” and selling over 20 million copies worldwide. Albums like Who’s Next (1971), with “Baba O’Riley” and “Won’t Get Fooled Again,” solidified their commercial peak, moving millions of units and dominating charts. Critically, they were lauded for pushing boundaries—Tommy and Quadrophenia (1973) showcased Pete Townshend’s ambitious songwriting and the band’s dynamic interplay. Artistically, their conceptual depth and theatrical live shows (think Keith Moon’s chaos and Townshend’s windmills) were unmatched. Their ability to rock? Explosive—literally, with Moon’s drum kit antics and Roger Daltrey’s primal screams.

AC/DC, formed in 1973, took a rawer, more primal route. By 1980, they’d unleashed Highway to Hell (1979) and Back in Black (1980), the latter selling over 50 million copies globally, making it one of the best-selling albums ever. Hits like “You Shook Me All Night Long” and “Highway to Hell” defined their relentless, riff-driven sound. Sales-wise, Back in Black alone outpaced The Who’s entire catalog in this period. Critics initially dismissed them as simplistic, but their consistency and energy won respect over time. Artistically, AC/DC leaned on straightforward, gritty blues-rock—less innovative than The Who, but honed to perfection by Angus Young’s electrifying solos and Bon Scott’s (later Brian Johnson’s) swaggering vocals. Their face-rocking prowess? Undeniable—AC/DC’s wall-of-sound live shows were a visceral assault.

In this era, The Who had more hits and critical acclaim, their artistic merit elevated by complex narratives and musical daring. AC/DC, however, surged ahead in record sales and delivered a tighter, more universal rock punch. The Who rocked with cerebral fury; AC/DC rocked with unadulterated grit. If you want your face melted by sophistication, The Who win. If you crave pure, unfiltered power, AC/DC take it. Both, in their prime, were titans—just with different weapons.
 
If you're going that way, then death and retirement should count as breaking up.
If the band remains active with original personnel after the death or retirement of members, is it broken up? Because we could make that argument on the Stones. The Who flat out, broke up in 1982, 4 years after the death of Keith Moon and had recorded "Face Dances" and "It's Hard" with Kenney Jones. The reunited for one year in 1989, broke up again until 1996. So that's not disbanding due to the death of key personnel, rather just quitting.

AC/DC lost Bon Scott in 1980, hired Brian Johnson that same year, released "Back In Black" and sold 50 million albums on that release alone. That fact alone shows the resilience of the band and the adoration of the fans. They could've easily turned their backs on them but they not only supported them? They worshipped them even more for toughing it out. Replacing a singer successfully is extremely difficult
 
Back
Top