strat style....volume knob in the right place

I mean, I have many different guitars. Not like we all can't play them. But not the ideal place for a volume knob IMO. Doesn't mean we can't play that guitar.
Look ag the Tele. Put the PU selector to the right and try and adjust the volume. It almost hits that switch! Stupid design but people can play em.

tele-oral-history-feature@1400x1050.jpg

The Telecaster is wrong on so many levels, but the country pickers idolize them for their sound.
 
I used to have a really long list of preferences and I was convinced certain guitars played better or sounded better than others.

Then, I started working in the studio on a full time basis and all of that began to melt away.

When we listened to a playback, there wasn't any tangible difference between one single coil guitar and another - and one humbucker guitar - and the other. They all sounded the same....and they sound even more similar when compared live in a noisy hall.

But, personal preferences are the life blood of this industry. Each new product will make you play faster or sound better, but in reality, it's all in the mind.

What makes you better is perfecting your technique
 
My guitars with anemic pickups certainly sound different from others. There are character differences even with higher gain. More treble, darker, ballsier...

Listen to a playback and watch the waveforms.

What we see with lower output pickups, is less volume and slightly less gain production, but very little difference in character. Nothing you could perceive in a noisy club.

But, you may hear subtitles with headphones on, but that's also very subjective.

We listen in hopes of justifying our investment or confirming theories.

One of the best producers I ever worked for told me once, "Be careful what you listen for. You just might hear it."
 
Listen to a playback and watch the waveforms.

What we see with lower output pickups, is less volume and slightly less gain production, but very little difference in character. Nothing you could perceive in a noisy club.

But, you may hear subtitles with headphones on, but that's also very subjective.

We listen in hopes of justifying our investment or confirming theories.

One of the best producers I ever worked for told me once, "Be careful what you listen for. You just might hear it."
I don't care less what the punters in the club hear.
I am the one standing in front of my amp.
I don't need a waveform.
The Ibby QM2 has less gain and sustain than the LP,pickups or the SD distortion I put in the other Ibby Prestige.
The Godin XTSA has way less high end, is darker substantially from most of my other guitars. I am not saying they are all night and day different but some have definite tonal and distortion character.
Switch guitars between songs live and listen.
Do not change EQ and see.
I need to justify nothing.
 
Speaking of producers, I used the Godin on one song we did. He asked me which pickup I was using, sounded like neck.
It wasn't.
The other gal plays an EPI LP. He liked the differences as hers added some high emd my guitar lacked. Mine was heavier.
I might not do QC for guitars but I have played a good many over 40 years. I know what I hear with some of them.
If you don't believe it, not my problem.
 
I mean, I have many different guitars. Not like we all can't play them. But not the ideal place for a volume knob IMO. Doesn't mean we can't play that guitar.
Look ag the Tele. Put the PU selector to the right and try and adjust the volume. It almost hits that switch! Stupid design but people can play em.

tele-oral-history-feature@1400x1050.jpg

Not to mention the ashtray that has to be reached over to strum the strings. :D
 
Speaking of producers, I used the Godin on one song we did. He asked me which pickup I was using, sounded like neck.
It wasn't.
The other gal plays an EPI LP. He liked the differences as hers added some high emd my guitar lacked. Mine was heavier.
I might not do QC for guitars but I have played a good many over 40 years. I know what I hear with some of them.
If you don't believe it, not my problem.

I'm not here to try and change your opinion. You're entitled to it.

On most stages, if your playing with stage volume, you can't even hear your amplifier unless you are standing in just the right spot, but even then, it's not a full sonic representation.

I've only been QC'ing guitars for 3 months. Thats not relevant to this discussion, but I've played for many years myself. My experiences are drastically different.
 
I'm not here to try and change your opinion. You're entitled to it.

On most stages, if your playing with stage volume, you can't even hear your amplifier unless you are standing in just the right spot, but even then, it's not a full sonic representation.

I've only been QC'ing guitars for 3 months. Thats not relevant to this discussion, but I've played for many years myself. My experiences are drastically different.
If I cant hear it I am standing in the wrong place!
I usually alternate 3 guitars per show and I can say that some definitely sound different, albeit subtly, than others. I have to change EQ or gain in some cases.
 
That could be. I'm a southpaw that plays right handed, so that could be a factor. On the other hand, even though I'm not totally ambidextrous, I am multi dextrous, doing many things with both hands equally well, and doing some things exclusively lefty and some things exclusively righty. I admire anyone who can move from one type of guitar to another seamlessly, that's a real blessing for a session player. My ambition doesn't run that direction, though. As long as my instruments are comfortable to me and make the variety of noises that please my ears, I'm good.
I to am a lefty and multindexterois something my elementary school teachers never could grasp , i cut right handed but was always stuck using these archaic contraptions that only resemble cutting instruments .20220427_031317.jpg
 
For me the nearby knob on Strat types is occasionally a bit annoying but not any real impediment.
At least it's always within easy reach. Les Paul volumes aren't ideal either but I'm long accustomed to those.

For me the perfect placement is the volume knob on most PRS models.
Never in the way yet it's right there when you want it.
 
How can you not hear your amp ?? I think this photo was 36 years ago every amp had a microphone on it back then and now
hear the mix through the monitors and mains I still have the 135 watt Twin amp Billy Zoom modified for me.

View attachment 83323

That's an awesome throwback pic.

We seldom had the luxury of miking and using a PA with monitors for the guitars. Most smaller bands that we see today don't have or use a snake with multiple instrument microphones.

In general, we ran only the drums and vocals through the monitors and all the guitars were running at stage volume and we "mixed" this during the soundcheck.

If you've never played on a stage with a setup like that, it's very different. With my Marshall Origin 50 on 6-7, the sound literally travels past you and it can be very difficult to hear your amp clearly.

I once heard a producer actually name this phenomenon, but I cannot recall the terminology he used.

Some guys will keep turning up the amp in an effort to hear it, to no avail, but their sonic "beam" is shaving heads in the back row.

Now, there have been occasions, while working with some bands for hire, that I've had a mixed amp with a dedicated instrument and vocal monitor. I think that's the best setup, but again, very few "bar bands" out here have that kind of equipment.

Additionally, in many situations where I have performed with a miked amp and a soundman, the mix has been less than stellar. If a soundman is really, really good at what he does, it can work very, very well....but at most of these events, will find yourself with too much or too little in your monitors.

TBTH, I prefer running the amps at stage volume and mixing the volume levels as we go.

In 'Bad Dog,' we had a sound tech who controlled the drum and vocal mix FOH with the board. At the time, we were using a huge, and very old, PA amp, JBL subs and PA speakers on 6 foot stands.

It's interesting that my wife has some recordings of these performances and it is surprisingly well mixed, but keep in mind that its the "old way" of doing things and there's a certain art to it.

Later on, we adopted the Beheringer X-Air which greatly reduced how much equipment we were hauling around.

At the end of the day, It would be great to be wealthy and/or retired and have unlimited resources to devote to a band's equipment, but that's not a reality for many of us in working bands that depend on their performances to earn a living.

Now, lately I've been giving a lot of thought to putting another band together for myself and call it "No More Bullsh*t."

I think I liked it better than just working as a 'hired guest.' But, therein lies another problem.

Most musicians that I know are retired and/or fairly wealthy and you can hardly get them to commit to showing up at a rehearsal. There are always last minute reschedules or cancelations.

Recently, our band at the Music Academy voted to move rehearsals from Saturdays at noon to Friday nights at 6pm. This was tough for me, because I'm working late on Fridays now, but I went along with the vote of the majority.

It struck me as kind of ironic that, after we moved the schedule around to accommodate certain members, it was those certain members who made last minute cancelations the very next week.

I'm very dedicated to whatever task is at hand, and it's hard to find people who feel the same way.

Anyways, hope you guys have a great week...

FB_IMG_1620082161405.jpg

FB_IMG_1620050085040.jpg

output.jpg

FB_IMG_1622409997674.jpg
 
Back
Top