I've been on a bit of an amp journey. As a teenager I had a Peavey Rage 158. I didn't really have a point of reference but always thought it sounded like crap. When I got back into playing a few (not so few anymore) years ago, after not having touched a guitar in 15 years, I got the Yamaha THR 5 (I still have it) which was brand new on the market at the time. To my inexperienced ears it sounded great.
I then joined a guitar forum and learned that if I wanted really great tonez I needed a tube amp. Said and done, I went to the local guitar store and got an overprized Peavey Nanovalve, it didn't sound good at all. Those guys on the interwebs were obviously full of crap, or I just got the wrong tube amp. I then got a Fender Greta, fun but not that great. Then I got a Hughes and Kettner Tubemeister 18, that one was actually really good but it wasn't the sound I was after, much too modern sounding when driven hard. It's still an amp I'd highly recommend to anyone though.
Since I still liked the THR 5 I figured I'd try the THR 100, because how could I go wrong with that? I liked the little brother and about 50% of people on the interwebs claimed modeling amp superiority, only contradicted by the 50% that claimed tube amp superiority. My odds seemed pretty good. The Yamaha THR 100 was not bad at all but I had expected something that sounded as good as the THR 5, I just didn't feel I got that. Plus it was pretty big for a modeling amp and not that convenient to haul to rehearsals (I had just joined my first band in 20 years). So maybe I needed a tube combo? I got the Fender Ramparte (still have it), it sounds good but it's too loud for home use, even too loud for band practice, has no FX loop etc. etc. This is where I came to the conclusion that I didn't want one practice amp and one amp for band situations, I wanted one amp, period.
Where to go from there then? Maybe I should try a solid state amp I thought. But how could those be any good? I mean both interweb camps, tube and modeling, seemed to agree on one thing; SS amps suck. They are unreliable, sound OK clean but sound like crap if you drive them, they are barely functional as small home practice amps. This seemed to go hand in hand with my own vast SS amp experiences (remember the Rage 158?). Anyway, I heard about Quilter and eventually found a used one locally. Now this was an amp I bonded with.
I then stumbled upon a used BluGuitar Amp 1 that I just had to try. I loved a few sounds from it but not so much other sounds. It was very convenient though, 100 watts in a pedal format, great EQ section, a small tube that actually seemed to do stuff etc. I put the Quilter up for sale but nobody wanted it (lucky). One day was fighting with a backing track, it was pretty crowded and I had a hard time cutting through. I brought out the Quilter and still had a hard time, in frustration I kicked the footswitch to engage the crunch channel, a channel that I generally don't like very much. It has a preset EQ that bypasses the EQ section of the amp and it sounds kind of bland to me on its own. Instant success though, I suddenly came through loud and clear. I sold the Amp 1 that same week and put the Quilter on my pedal board together with an OD pedal and a reverb pedal.
Sometimes I look at yout00b reviews of other amps, I've looked at the Marshall JTM45, the DSL series, the Origin series, Fender Bassbreaker, Pro Jr. Bassman etc. None of them do (to my ears) anything that I can't make the Quilter do, at least reasonably well. If something better shows up one day I'll switch amps again and I don't care if it is tube, modeling or SS but this far, nothing has beaten the Quilter for my needs.
The moral of the story kids? Astral Traveler is right and everyone else on the interwebs is wrong!! Muahahahahaha!!!
Below is my amp journey in yout00b clips. The really depressing part is that when listening back, I don't think I've improved my playing in those 5 years, it might actually have gotten worse
Peavey Nanovalve:
(1) Sunset noodling - YouTube
Fender Greta:
(1) Moving mountains - YouTube
Hughes&Kettner:
(1) Unshackle me baby! - YouTube
Yamaha THR 100H:
(1) At the strike of twelve - YouTube
Fender Ramparte:
(1) Dark of night - YouTube
BluGuitar Amp 1:
(1) Day 5 - YouTube
Quilter Overdrive 200:
(1) Sad Little Heart - YouTube