Scott Baxendale
Well-Known Member
These are about 1/3 the price of an equivalent Martin and sounds as good or better than the best vintage Martin OOO-18’s.
She is playing the holy grail of vintage flattops here. This is the type of sound we are aiming for. Some of the rebuild get real close for pennies on the dollar in comparison. This guitar is probably around $50-60k. Ours are between $1000-3000. Molly Tuttle is also one of todays best pickers too.
Yep ..that guitar sounds good for sure. It's a little hard to hear with the stage ambiance and performance mixing in but I can tell "it's there". Your OP guitar sounds pretty good as well but in my opinion it's not keeping up with a Martin and is most definitely not a "Martin Crusher". Lol.She is playing the holy grail of vintage flattops here. This is the type of sound we are aiming for. Some of the rebuild get real close for pennies on the dollar in comparison. This guitar is probably around $50-60k. Ours are between $1000-3000. Molly Tuttle is also one of todays best pickers too.
Here is Mark O’Conner playing a guitar my son, John Baxendale, built for him awhile back. Our specialty since I began building guitar was to try and make guitars that compared directly to the golden age of Martin and Gibson, which in Martin’s case was from 1934-1938. John started building guitars with me in 2001, after helping me in the repair shop since he was 5.
I’m less into the bluegrass/flat picker scene but here is one I built for Jimmy Herring.
These are built from scratch which is different than the rebuilds. The rebuilds are a much greener process and allows to put our sound into guitars average folks can afford. My customs are only bought by lawyers and doctors because the base price is $7500. On a $7500 custom I only end up making around $24 per hour after overhead.
I have a 1939 O-17 which is great. I have a 1970 00-18 and I have a 1970 D-8 which I’m about to rebuild and rebrace the top like a 34 D-18. I’ve owned lots of martins. Mostly pre 1975.Yep ..that guitar sounds good for sure. It's a little hard to hear with the stage ambiance and performance mixing in but I can tell "it's there". Your OP guitar sounds pretty good as well but in my opinion it's not keeping up with a Martin and is most definitely not a "Martin Crusher". Lol.
I'm really big on Martins and have 3.....
GPC-18e, 00-14 Slope Shoulder Custom Shop, GPC-Aura GT
![]()
To me all 3 completely hit the mark on tone, look, and feel. I'd never need another acoustic having only one of them to be honest. Martin still carries the torch by far IMO.
I’ve got a customer who plays with Zac Brown and Clint Black who used to tour with his prewar martins. He has several 30’s martins that he paid manythousands for. After he got his first Baxendale Conversion, which was a 40’s era OM size spruce over mahogany with a figure 8 shaped body we recorded them side by side and they were so dang close that he bought a second one and now only tours with the conversions. Nearly every time he goes into the studio with one either one of the other musicians or the producer contacts me about getting one in their studio. We’ve been on multiple Grammy winning albums.Yep ..that guitar sounds good for sure. It's a little hard to hear with the stage ambiance and performance mixing in but I can tell "it's there". Your OP guitar sounds pretty good as well but in my opinion it's not keeping up with a Martin and is most definitely not a "Martin Crusher". Lol.
I'm really big on Martins and have 3.....
GPC-18e, 00-14 Slope Shoulder Custom Shop, GPC-Aura GT
![]()
To me all 3 completely hit the mark on tone, look, and feel. I'd never need another acoustic having only one of them to be honest. Martin still carries the torch by far IMO.
I’m hearing a LOT of likable tones there! Lots of recognizable, classic, stuff. Thanks for sharing!These are about 1/3 the price of an equivalent Martin and sounds as good or better than the best vintage Martin OOO-18’s.